Pros and Cons of Granite and Solid Surface Countertops

Printer Friendly Version
  Solid Surface Granite
Excellent image quality
Good resale value
Consistent color quality  
Wide color range
Integrated Sinks
(no seam, lip or recess to trap dirt)
 
Superior scratch resistance1  
Superior heat resistance2  
Fire retardant  
Superior stain restance  
Bacteria resistance3  
Mold/mildew resistance3  
Non-porous  
Renewable & repairable  
Smooth, solid, inconspicuous seams  
Unlimited edge options  
Detailed options
(seamless coved backsplash, custom drainboard)
 
Overall design flexibility  
Requires annual sealing  
10 Year Installed, Transferable Warranty  

 
1 Solid Surface: Cutting boards are recommended by most solid surface manufacturers. Scratches can be buffed away. Granite: Damage to sealant may occur when cutting directly on a granite countertop.
2 Solid Surface: Minor heat damage usually can be repaired by the homeowner, and more severe heat damage can be inconspicuously repaired by a certified installer. Granite: Extreme or prolonged exposure to heat may damage the sealant.
3 Solid Surface: Gibraltar and Earthstone Solid Surface meet the following standards: ASTM G21 & G22 for fungal and bacterial resistance; NSF Class 51 for food and splash zones; and FDA compliance for food contact. Granite: The natural stone industry has developed several specialized products and procedures to protect surfaces from some of the conditions mentioned above. Go to www.stonecare.com for details.
Sources:
The Buyers Guide to Selecting Granite Counter Tops, Frederick M. Heuston, 2002, NTC Enterprises, Inc.
Caring for Your Granite Countertop, by Frederick M. Heuston, 1997, NTC Enterprises, Inc.
International Solid Surface Fabricators Association / www.issfa.com
Marble Institute of America / www.marble-institute.com
National Training Center for Stone & Masonry Trades / www.ntc-stone.com
Building Materials Supplies / www.bmsco.net/nc.html
Stone Care International / www.stonecare.com